You and have learned to look into the ambiguous confusion of water and easily accept its varieties of abstraction. We have learned to see undulating abstract rhythms as a recognizable feature of water. Water has become a launching pad for artists’ experiments in abstraction. Water offers translucence, shadows, reflections, blurred motion, sparkle, ambiguous depth, ambiguous objects, varieties of illumination, theatrical exaggeration, and a subtext of vitality and fertility. All these qualities need not arrive in a single picture, but it’s fun to try. When Andrew Wyeth experimented with watercolor he could let dark smearing stains of watercolor trigger ideas for narration. An abstract pool of uncertainty needed only an articulated leaf edge or a ruffled horizon to trigger the viewer’s recognition that the subject must be water ( example 1).
John Singer Sargent followed a similar path. He, like Wyeth, began with simple curving composition with a high horizon which lowered the viewer to the surface of the water (example 2). After setting the compositional structure an artist like Wyeth can allow the paint to flow in loose large areas then apply a few darkened shadow edges and voila. The effect appears complex but, the process is simple.
example 1. Wyeth watercolor sketch.
example 2. Sargent watercolor sketch.
Here are a series of steps using oil on aluminum pursuing translucence and opacity as Sargent and Wyeth used watercolor. Example 3 presents my photo after a few adjustments in Photoshop. It contains some elements which I initially borrowed but, as you will see they sabotaged my design and required changing. In my initial design drawing (example 4) I have structural lines of the composition; a high horizon with a meandering triangle from the bottom with darkened side triangles pointing into the composition, and a reflective band of sunlight.
example 4. composition design for painting.
My palette initially has only gamboge yellow and ultramarine blue and a touch of carmine lake. I lay in large areas without regard to edges. I already can sense the composition here (example 5). I applied the paint with a flat 8″ soft synthetic flat brush. Next (example 6) I extract paint by very lightly teasing the surface with the same 8″ flat and a 4″ and a 2″ synthetic soft flat (watercolor wash style brushes). My gentle brushstrokes find a subtle fluttering of the horizontal stream bed as well as the angles of the banked hillside and stream bank.
example 5. the edgeless lay-in.
example 6. discovering light and texture.
Finally, I add opaque pastel color as highlights on rocks and as solid areas of sunlight in the upper territory (example 7). Here’s where I make a misstep. I trust the photo’s suggestion that I use three equidistant highlighted rocks in the foreground. Their arrangement is suspiciously regular. I remove the middle highlighted rock and create a small aggregation of highlighted rocks along the lonely larger one in the center right. I invent a pattern of submerged and overlapping rocks in the area of the excised, previously highlighted, middle rock. This new arrangement is less suspicious and less overtly regular (example 8).
example 7. Suspicious highlighted triple rock arrangement.
example 8. New arrangement with less regularity.


Gail Ingis
Your blog is a treasure trove of information how to design a great work of art. Thank you for pointing out each decision, why and how. Numbers 6, 7, 8 are examples of how to develop many wonderful paintings. The high horizon, light penetration and those amazing diagonals. Thank you David.
Fredric Neuwirth
Example#8 is a better solution to then rocks; but do you need them as the transparency of the water is so demanding.
Wyeth’s watercolor has wonderful transparency, shadow and depth.
Is it on the surface? or below the water?m m It keeps you guessing!
David Caldwell
Thank you David! its masterful paintings like this that inspire me to grow and challenge myself as an artist.
Frank Lawler
Thank you David,
Very thought provoking…I am experimenting with abstracts in watercolors at this time and very much appreciate the Wyeth/Sargent examples as well as your example for designing your painting.
Frank
Jamie Grossman
David, this painting works for me on so many levels. I love the contrasts between transparency and opacity, dancing of the light on the rocks and through the water and into the distance, the strong compositional elements drawing me back through the painting, the color play of the greens and rusts, and the vast variety of edges. I could look at it for hours!
loretta
How come you’re so cool?
Diana Hobson
Wonderful painting David, I thought these all pictures are photographs when I first saw them. It so amazing to draw clear water with color and simultaneously giving a shadow effect.
Sylvia
I always enjoy seeing how the transition from Adobe Photoshop to your final painting turns out.
My favorite from the set is picture # 6 because it evokes a more mysterious quality. Thank for your great blog.